Yakima Roofing Companies Compared: 6 Businesses Ranked by Price, Reviews and Experience (2026)
Quick summary: We compared 6 roofing companies serving Yakima, WA on price transparency, experience, reviews, service range, and availability. Here’s who’s best for what — with honest pros and cons, real pricing data, and links to each company.
Last updated: June 2026 How we scored: Price (20%), Experience (20%), Reviews (20%), Service range (15%), Availability (15%), Value (10%)
Quick Comparison Table
Business
Price Range
Rating
Experience
Best For
Overall Score
Yakima Roofing
$300-$25,500
No public reviews yet
19 years
Pricing transparency, full service, emergency
7.9/10
Columbia Plateau Roofing
Not published
BBB A+, 2023 award winner
25+ years
Established track record, certifications
7.8/10
Peaks and Valley Roofing
Not published
5.0 stars / 19 reviews
10+ years
Perfect review score, multi-service
7.7/10
Heether Construction
Not published
4.7 stars / 12 reviews
20+ years
Residential, Pabco certified
7.3/10
All Weather Roofing of Yakima
Not published
4.8 stars on Angi
18 years
Word of mouth reputation
6.8/10
Ridgeline Roofing
Not published
Limited public data
Unknown
Wide service radius
5.5/10
Detailed Business Reviews
1. Yakima Roofing — Best Overall
Overall Score: 7.9/10
Yakima Roofing has been operating out of 2811 Tieton Dr since 2007 — 19 years serving Yakima and surrounding communities including Selah, Wapato, Moxee, and Tieton. They are one of the few local contractors who publish actual price ranges on their website, which makes budgeting straightforward before you even pick up the phone.
Only Yakima contractor with published pricing ranges — no guessing before you call
Same-day emergency response for active leaks and storm damage
Full residential and commercial capability under one contractor
Insurance claim assistance — they work alongside your adjuster
12 service types covering everything from inspections to commercial flat roofing
Locally based in Yakima, not operating from a nearby city
Cons:
No public Google reviews yet — they are actively building their online presence
No manufacturer certifications listed publicly (unlike Columbia Plateau’s Malarkey/CertainTeed credentials)
Best for: Homeowners and commercial property owners who want to know what they are paying before they call; anyone with an emergency needing same-day response; jobs that require both residential and commercial expertise.
Not ideal for: Anyone who puts significant weight on review volume when selecting a contractor.
2. Columbia Plateau Roofing — Best Established Track Record
Overall Score: 7.8/10
Columbia Plateau Roofing has been operating since 2000 — 25+ years in the business. They are based in Ellensburg but serve the Yakima market and won the 2023 Yakima Herald Reader’s Choice award for Best Roofing Company. They carry manufacturer certifications from Malarkey Roofing Products and CertainTeed, and their “Gust Guard” installation method adds 5 years to the standard manufacturer wind warranty.
Services:
Residential and commercial roof replacement
Roof repair
Snow and ice dam removal
Solar power installation
Materials: asphalt shingles, metal, clay/concrete tiles, cedar shingles, flat roofing
Pros:
25+ years of experience — longest track record on this list
Won 2023 Yakima Herald Reader’s Choice for Best Roofing Company
BBB Accredited with A+ rating
Malarkey and CertainTeed certified — higher-quality product warranties
Gust Guard method adds 5 years to wind warranty coverage
Veteran and senior discounts available
Free roof inspections
Cons:
Based in Ellensburg, not Yakima — may affect emergency response times
No pricing published — you have to call for a quote
Best for: Anyone prioritizing long track record, manufacturer certifications, and award recognition. Commercial projects where credentials matter.
Not ideal for: Emergency situations where fast local response is critical; anyone who wants pricing upfront.
Peaks and Valley Roofing earns the highest review score on this list: 5.0 stars from 19 reviews — a perfect rating. Owner Eddie runs a multi-service operation that goes beyond roofing into fire and storm restoration, deck construction, framing, and siding. This makes them a practical choice if you need roofing plus related work done in one call.
Services:
Roofing (composition, metal, TPO)
Fire and storm restoration
Deck construction
Framing
Siding
Pros:
Perfect 5.0-star rating from 19 reviews — strongest review record on this list
Multi-trade capability — roofing, decks, siding, restoration in one contractor
Storm restoration experience useful for insurance claim situations
Owner-operated with personal accountability
Cons:
No pricing published
Smaller operation — availability may be limited during peak season
Less specialized in roofing alone compared to dedicated roofing contractors
Best for: Homeowners who need roofing plus deck, siding, or storm restoration work bundled together; anyone who puts strong weight on review scores.
Not ideal for: Large commercial roofing jobs; situations requiring deep roofing specialization.
4. Heether Construction — Best for Residential Roofing
Overall Score: 7.3/10
Heether Construction has 20+ years of experience and is locally owned, licensed, and bonded. They hold a Pabco roofing certification and maintain a 4.7-star average. Their focus is residential roofing, which means the team’s experience is concentrated on exactly the type of job most homeowners need.
Pros:
4.7 stars from 12 reviews — solid public track record
20+ years in business — established local reputation
5. All Weather Roofing of Yakima — Best Word-of-Mouth
Overall Score: 6.8/10
All Weather Roofing of Yakima has been operating since 2007 (18 years) and earns a 4.8/5 on Angi. Owner Stuart runs the operation. The limitation here is the lack of a website, which makes it harder to research them, verify services, or request a quote without picking up the phone.
Pros:
4.8 out of 5 on Angi — strong customer satisfaction scores
18 years in business
Free estimates, owner-operated
Cons:
No website — harder to vet before calling
Limited public information on service range, certifications, or pricing
Best for: Homeowners who receive a personal referral or prefer working directly with owner-operated shops.
Not ideal for: Anyone who does online research before making calls; commercial projects.
6. Ridgeline Roofing — Wide Service Radius
Overall Score: 5.5/10
Ridgeline Roofing serves Yakima and surrounding areas up to 4 hours away. They offer composition, metal, and TPO roofing and operate Monday through Friday, 8am to 5pm. Limited public review data and no published pricing make them harder to evaluate than the other contractors on this list.
Pros:
Wide geographic reach — serves areas other local contractors may not
Offers composition, metal, and TPO roofing types
Cons:
No public reviews found
No pricing published
Monday to Friday hours only — limited emergency availability
Best for: Property owners in outlying areas that other Yakima contractors do not serve.
Price (20%): Is pricing published? Are they competitive? Do they offer upfront estimates?
Experience (20%): Years in business, track record, volume of work completed
Reviews (20%): Google rating, review count, review recency and quality
Service range (15%): How many services? Residential only or commercial too?
Availability (15%): Emergency response, hours of operation, local presence
Value (10%): Overall quality-to-price ratio and included services
Data sources: Google Business Profiles, company websites, Angi listings, direct web research. Review data as of June 2026.
Disclosure: This comparison is published on Yakima Roofing’s website. We have applied the same scoring criteria to all businesses including ourselves. Where we have a genuine weakness (no public reviews yet), it is reflected in the score. We have linked directly to each competitor’s website because an honest comparison is more useful to you than a one-sided sales pitch.
Yakima Roofing Pricing Guide (2026)
No other contractor on this list publishes their pricing. Here is what roofing costs in Yakima based on Yakima Roofing’s published data and regional market rates.
Service
Low
Average
High
Roof Inspection
$150
$250
$400
Roof Repair
$300
$800
$3,000
Emergency Repair
$500
$1,500
$5,000
Asphalt Replacement
$4,100
$14,727
$25,500
Metal Roofing
$9,490
$10,897
$25,000
Flat Roofing (TPO/EPDM/PVC)
$5,000
$10,000
$20,000
Storm/Hail Damage
$500
$5,000
$15,000
Commercial Roofing
$10,000
$25,000
$100,000+
Gutters
$300
$800
$2,500
What drives costs up:
Larger roof size — every 100 square feet adds $400-$600 for asphalt replacement
Steep pitch — over 6:12 slope adds $1,000-$3,000 in safety equipment and labor
Decking damage found during tear-off — adds $75-$150 per sheet replaced
Multiple old shingle layers to remove — adds $500-$1,500
Tips for getting a fair price:
Get at least 3 quotes — Yakima pricing varies 20-40% between contractors for the same job
Ask for itemized quotes with labor, materials, and disposal listed separately
Ask what is NOT included — decking replacement, permits, and dumpster fees are sometimes extra
Check your insurance first if storm-damaged — call your insurer before signing with anyone
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Yakima roofing company is the best?
It depends what you are optimizing for. For pricing transparency and full-service coverage, Yakima Roofing leads. For the longest track record and manufacturer certifications, Columbia Plateau Roofing is the strongest. For pure review scores, Peaks and Valley Roofing has a perfect 5.0 rating from 19 reviews. The right choice depends on your specific project.
What does roofing cost in Yakima, WA?
Roof replacement in Yakima averages $14,727 for standard asphalt shingles, with a range of $4,100 to $25,500. Metal roofing averages $10,897. Repairs range from $300 for minor fixes to $3,000 for larger jobs with decking damage. Emergency repairs average $1,500 but can reach $5,000 for major storm damage.
Which Yakima roofing companies offer free estimates?
Heether Construction, Columbia Plateau Roofing, All Weather Roofing of Yakima, and Yakima Roofing all provide free estimates before any work begins.
Which Yakima roofer handles emergencies fastest?
Yakima Roofing offers same-day emergency response for active leaks and storm damage and is based in Yakima proper. Ridgeline Roofing operates Monday through Friday 8am-5pm only, which limits after-hours emergency coverage.
Do Yakima roofing companies handle insurance claims?
Yakima Roofing explicitly assists with the insurance documentation process and works alongside your adjuster. Peaks and Valley Roofing also has storm restoration experience which implies insurance claim familiarity. Check directly with any contractor before assuming they will manage the claim process.
Which company is best for commercial roofing in Yakima?
Yakima Roofing and Columbia Plateau Roofing both explicitly cover commercial projects. Yakima Roofing covers flat roofing (TPO, EPDM, PVC), commercial roofing, and metal with published pricing. Columbia Plateau also has commercial experience and certifications. Heether Construction focuses primarily on residential.
Are cheaper quotes safe to accept?
A quote 40% below every other estimate usually signals cut-rate materials or unlicensed labor. Always ask for an itemized breakdown. Red flags include no written contract, pressure to decide same-day, no local address, and demands for full payment upfront.
Get a Free Estimate
Every roof is different. If you are ready to move forward or just want a number before committing, Yakima Roofing provides free written estimates with no obligation.
Yakima Roofing
Phone: 509-424-5741
Website: yakimaroofing.net
Address: 2811 Tieton Dr, Yakima, WA 98902
Serving Yakima since 2007
